skyjedi2005 said:Williams did write and score music for television even though he cannot be labaled as a tv composer, he was a movie composer of symphonic orchetstral scores. The Scale of his works written for the LSO is not even comparable to a small tv hollywood orchestra. Kiner is a tv composer, and as such writes for a different medium and his scores are tonally different completely.
You really suffer from a terminal case of Cranial Insertus Analatus, don't you?
Williams did PLENTY of TV scores early in his career, most notably the Irwin Allen 60's series Lost In Space, Time Tunnel and Land Of The Giants.
You're also not comparing them on the same level. Williams has twice the time in the industry as Kiner, so naturally his body of work is going to overshadow a lot of the younger guys.
The fair comparison is Kiner and McNeely, who did Shadows Of The Empire. Both of them have about the same amount of time in the industry, and both of them are re-interpreting Williams' work on the SW films for the projects they were assigned to.
That being said, the only reason McNeely might rate higher is because his score was done during a different attitude in the history of SW EU. Shadows was designed to look and feel like it was always a part of the SW universe but we just never heard about it until now. Clone Wars is trying for more of its own identity, part of SW but purposely having a different artistic style.