LordVader said: Don't get me wrong, when I saw my first lightsaber duel between old Ben and Vader I was in awe, now lets compare that to the choreographed masterpiece between Ray Park, Ewan McGregor, and Liam Neeson, truth be told fightwise there is no comparison, but its understandable Obi Wan is old and Darth Vader is well past his prime, that's not to say I don't enjoy the old fights, especially Adywan's remix of it.
That's the problem with the Phantom Menace duel to me- it FELT choreographed, and as such, there was little suspense or tension. The best duel to me was in ESB. It felt like a real duel, not like a predictable dance routine. There were surprising moments all throughout the duel and you could feel Luke struggling towards the end- his weariness was tangible. I didn't get any of that from the duel in TPM.