rcb said:
im srry, but its annoying to see how plain puppets look sometimes.sy nootles is way better off as a cgi character.

Sy Snootles as a cgi character was one of the stand out problems of the special edition mutilation of Star Wars. The cartoonishness of the cgi totally didn't fit the established style and mentality of Star Wars and the film. It was awful. The OT's puppets generally work fine, cgi all too often looks unreal and Star Wars cgi particularly so.

C3PX said:
It is dumb we are having a debate as to which version of Sy Snootles was a better character. Sy is a pretty lame character either way. The CG Sy scene just made the scene all the worse by making it longer than it already was and making it an over the top caricature of the original scene. In its 1997/2004 incarnations, it is the kind of scene that would make one embarrassed to be a Star Wars fan. I rank it right up there with "giant flee surfing" in my top five reasons why you might want to hide the fact that you like Star Wars.

The revised scene was certainly awful.