logo Sign In

Post #334959

Author
C3PX
Parent topic
Idea: STAR WARS REVISITED - The Ultrapurist edition (Tentatively Titled) (Not an Official Adywan production)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/334959/action/topic#334959
Date created
1-Nov-2008, 9:51 PM
negative1 said:

 since the final product wasn't said to be in HD,

it wouldn't really matter what the quality/resolution started off as (DVD),

since you wouldn't be able to tell..

later

-1

 

Who wouldn't be able to tell? Even on my small standard def. TV, the GOUT looks like crap compared to Adywan's nice and crisp Revisited discs. It doesn't have to be in HD to be better quality than the GOUT, the GOUT is absolute garbage. On my friends big widescreen TV, the GOUT is unwatchable, it feel like watching SW on youtube. However, the 04 discs look great on it (color issues aside). I think it is obvious you have never looked at the GOUT much, if you assume nobody would be able to tell the difference between it and a version restored from Ady's color corrected versions.

My biggest fear about this project, beside being a lot of work, would be it ending up looking like OCP's Classic Editions, which had the DVDs, with laserdisc bits taken to cover up the CG, which depending on the brightness of your TV, could look pretty unsightly and glaring.