Jedi --

Some good suggestions here. Just a few comments...

1. I don't think I'd cut the Doom Town scene. For all of it's uh... quirks... it's still pretty iconic. I do agree however that some trimming could be done especially to the fridge flying and rolling and bouncing.

2. There IS this weird pacing at work here between Ox's cell and the grave site, but i think (and topdawg as well) we shoot cut the childish dath of the blow gun guy and add gun fire here from Indy. Some trimming elsewhere might help as well.

3. Agree 100%. I would do it the exact same way.

4. I'd like to see one BIG waterfall by combining the 3 small ones. Something would have to be done about the drops three times dialog of course.

5. Agree 100%. I would do it the exact same way.

6. I'd have to see it again, but I don't mind "stop being a child" though I could see cutting "find something to fight with." Not sure about the Jones/Jonesey thing - would have to watch it again. Agree with cutting plants hitting Mutt's crotch. I'd really like to see your version without the monkeys. I remember in the theater thinking I had the perfect way to pull this off, but again I'l ahve to see the film again to remember.

7. Agree 100%. I would do it the exact same way.

8. Agree 100%. I would do it the exact same way. I'd like to see Indy leave the bastard. Maybe he can say the "god damn it, Mac..." line walk back down to help, grab for his whip, then Mac gets sucked away, then back to Indy who was knocked down by the blast, gets up and gets back to escaping with his family.

9. I would trim the school promotion. But keep part of it.

Ok, so these were just suggestions. Topdawg and I are having conversations trying to come to a consensus on an edit.

Question - i'm new to this - would it be easier for us to all come to a consensus and split the labor to create one ultimate version? Or do y'all each want to have your own version?