Sluggo said:
JediMasterFisher said:
vbangle said:
JediMasterFisher said:
I hate the yub yub ending. The SE is way better. The music is great and we see more which is needed.

Let me guess your under 20, right? Most young people love the 04' SE DVDs, most 40+ who remember the OUT as it was when we saw it IN PERSON, AT THE THEATER, prefer the OUT more. Or at least certain parts of it more....like the original ROTJ ending...

The SE music is LAME. It doesn't even keep to the tempo the people and ewoks are dancing to.

But this is all a mute argument. I respect Ady's decisions and choices for HIS edit....this is just one I don't happen to agree with...

However, the improvements to picture quality and getting rid of the 04 SE slave backup singers will more than make up for it....

I am under 20 yes but I grew with the pre SE ending and liked it but then saw the SE ending for the first time and realized that the old ending was weaker IMO. I like the new music so much it makes feel like the end of a saga IMO.

The music for the SE is one of the few things I like about it. No more of the damned Yub yub. And I am in my mid 30's.

I am not trying to pick a fight or stirr up any trouble, but why would the tempo of the ending music matter. It isn't source music. Only the audience is listening.

Why would the tempo matter?? It's a celebration, not a funeral! And the Ewoks were actually PLAYING the music, so not only the audience but everyone in the forest was listening. To me, its as sacrilegious to change that music (and, for that matter, Lapti Nek), as it would have been to change the Cantina music!

MY LAST POST IN THIS THREAD ON THIS SUBJECT!!! PROMISE!