adywan said:

Bingowings said:
Loving the return of the white walls and the red Sith sabre Ady but I also noticed that the blue tint actually helped the Cloud City exterior shots (possibly because it created an illusion of natural sunlight and hid some of the thick matte lines) those shots seem to be the only ones which looked better (in thumbnail at least) on the dreaded DVD version than after your clean up.

Actually the exterior matte shots have ahd a very pink tint added to them and other exterior shots have been reddened, which makes them look terrible and totally un-natural. If you look at the sky in the matte shots of the 2004 transfer the sky has had all blue stripped from it. There is a lot of work to be done on this edit.

You may notice I amended my earlier post as on closer inspection they didn't look better but not quite so hideous as the rest of the DVD alterations. The DVD version does hide a lot of the compositing hiccups but loses some of the contrast in the process.

I do appreciate how much hard work has already gone into this project, just looking at the comparisons shows that.