hempler said:
Think you are a little off by just saying the "Blu-ray" encode will be better than this one. Look at the difference between the 2004 DVD and Revisited. Ady's versions no matter what will probably look better than any of LFL versions of the film officially released on blu-ray unless his group does the same thing Ady is doing and fixing the color problems. And yes.....with proper encoding a 9GB version can look just as good.....mainly becasue alot of the blu-ray movies are not much bigger any way. The movies are around 12-15 GB and the extras on the rest. There are still alot of the movies coming out on the single layer blu-rays. Don't get me wrong.....there are many on the dual layer ones and the movies are much larger so the picture looks better in the dark and bright sequences. Do not discount Ady's versions as just re-encodes because I will put money on it that his versions will look better picture wise then the LFL releases.

"Better" is subjective. It's absolutely IMPOSSIBLE for the detail to be better on ady's than an official.

Again, I'm not discounting ady's. I will be downloading his immediately when they're released. In fact, his "revisited" was the very first (and up until this point, ONLY) fan edit I've ever downloaded and watched. I thought it was absolutely FANTASTIC.

Again, let's investigate how all of you are watching these things. Are you watching them on 42" screens? I hate to say it but there's not a single person on here that i'd trust to do an accurate review of any of these. Send them to the professional reviewers with 100"+ screens and then you'll see all the problems with the original mpeg-2 files.