dumb_kid said:1 - Oh common! Imagine how many better the fight will be! Why shouldn't adywan do that as he did with Obi vs. Vader in A New Hope?
It would also be better if he added some music as he did with ANH.
And the worst part is when Vader starts throwing things to Luke (with the force offcourse). It really looks fake!Those things won't hurt at that low speed. Maybe you can speed those things up?Face it xD ! The fight just isn't spectacular anymore. In my opinion it really has to be a little pimped!
2 - It doesn't matter if the prequels suck, the OriginalTrilogy is the future of the PrequelTrilogy. The interiors look prehistoric, not futuristic. That's why they could use a good makeover. They just don't fit anymore in the chronologic order.
1.There is lot more going on in this duel than just fighting. One thing the PT duel sorely lacked was any kind of emotional ebb and flow in the confrontations. The pacing is perfect. Little bit of fighting, then slow it down, more intense fighting, slow it down, even more fighting, big climax! (This technique works in other areas as well...)
The whole vader throwing stuff at luke scene is fine. The debris is flying around at a decent clip. Don't believe me, have a friend throw a garbage can at your head and see if it knocks you off balance.
2. This is a problem with the PT not the OT. Thankfully Ady has stated many times that he'll try to match the PT to the OT, not the other way around.
1 - He could speed up the parts where they fight, and keep the original speed when it slows down and they talk. In that way it keeps its emotional ebb and it would be so much more intense.
What about adding 'Battle of the Heroes' then (or another good song)? Adywan is considering it :D I hope he does add it!
2 - This isn't a problem with the PT. It is a problem with the time, the things (at this point the interiors) are ment to look futuristic, but they just don't, due time(And George couldn't use the older interiors in the newer PT, because they would have looked old). Like I said, they just don't fit anymore in the chronologic order.
And Adywan can fix that!
Cas_Tanje