lordjedi said:

skyjedi2005 said:

To be fair to negative 1 the dialogue is different in the final film than in the shooting script.

You want the llines as they were delivered in the film you need the transcripts aka continuity scripts.

I disagree. If you want the lines as they were delivered, you need to watch the movies. Only then can you get the tone, inflection, and the actors ability in it's true context. I'm sure if the lines had received the same delivery as the PT lines did, they'd be downright dry and boring.

do you think i would be going out too far on a limb to say that

1) i have a fair degree of certainty that anyone participating / commenting / arguing about any of the points in this thread

is in fact, actually, referring to the way the lines WERE DELIVERED IN THE MOVIES..................if someone is reading these

here for the first time without watching the movies (and reading all the spoilers also) they probably wouldn't comment,.......

i don't think anyones implying that just reading these lines here is giving them an indication of how they were delivered in the movie

2) that being said.......... i stand by my analysis, that the lines come across as flat, dry, and in fact a little slow paced..........

i have to admit that i've read Star Wars the novel/scripts etc....many many more times than i've ever watched the films..

i just started listening to the radio dramas and the vinyl versions a lot more recently...............which again, have a different

delivery.............................................. so maybe i'm more lenient on all the extra detail in the books, and in other formats,

but have less patience in the film versions.............

later

-1