Maybe I should have asked for ratings out of 10 instead of an order of preference.

Anyway, I devised a statistical method of weighting the "votes" above, and came up with this:

1. WALL·E               0.70
2. Toy Story            0.63
3. The Incredibles   0.58
4. Toy Story 2         0.54
5. Finding Nemo      0.53
6. Monsters, Inc.     0.44
7. Ratatouille          0.37
8. Cars                    0.34
9. A Bug's Life        0.25

(not sure how accurately this represents a summary of the posts above)

Compare with the IMDb ratings:

1    WALL·E (2008)             8.8
2    Ratatouille (2007), Incredibles, The (2004) & Finding Nemo (2003)     8.2
5    Toy Story (1995)          8.1
6    Monsters, Inc. (2001) & Toy Story 2 (1999)    8.0
8    Cars (2006)                 7.5
9    Bug's Life, A (1998)     7.3