Says you. It wouldn't be the first time in history that a film didn't do well at the box office but then had great home video sales.
Most of what they listed at that site are simply mistakes, not huge glaring plot holes. And again, so what? Does every movie have to be perfect in order to not be bad? Give me a break.
Wall-E was fun and enjoyable. I'm sorry that you didn't enjoy it (like you seem to not enjoy most Pixar movies). Pixar movies make me feel like a kid again. I'd say they're doing their job just fine.
i will say this:
1) you're right, a movie can do well on dvd and not in the theaters...
2) not every movie has to be perfect, but the imperfections have to be good enough/funny enough/not important enough/endearing to make a lasting impression
(ie. the original 'star wars', a galore of issues, but still classic to me)......................
3) you don't have to be sorry, it was only a movie..... i don't feel bad that PIXAR let me down yet again, because they'll be more movies coming out from them
whether i like them or not.. (their hit/miss ratio is pretty low for me)...
4) you seemed to miss the part, where i said TOY STORY was one of my all time favorite movies (flaws and all), that i have seen it more than STAR WARS,
and that i was really won over by 'the incredibles', and that CARS is slowly creeping up there to be one of my all time favorite animated movies also....
maybe i'm picky/biased/stickler for the movies i like, and don't care for everything someone (yes you PIXAR) throws out there for the public to
devour, and its about time the public realizes it also..maybe they're finally getting a clue..........
being a big computer graphics fan,
i used to wait for every animated movie to come out regardless of what it was (shrek/dinosaurs/chicken little, etc etc etc).......but after
a certain point, i realized almost ANYBODY can put out a computer animated movie..............so i had to have some criteria to separate the wheat
from the chaff............................................wall-e is apparently heading down the road of chaff................i might have been ambivalent before,
but rethinking it, makes me realize how sub-par and displeasing it really was..
later
-1