Yeah I aree with you totally on the editing, that is what makes a movie, you look at the rough draft footage shown on the Empire of Dreams Documentry of ANH and they're terrible. They're not just prequel bad, they're just plain bad bad. I don't know how the movie would've turned out if GL was in full control of editing, but I think it is better that we don't know. As for the music, I never really liked any of the work in the PT. In the OT, I think most of us would agree the music was perfect, but in the PT it never hit the spot for me. I think it was usually adequate, over the top often, it didn't seem like John Williams heart was into it like the OT.