Siliconmaster482 said:

Jor Tallen said:

I just watched magnoliafan's edit of Episode I. He did an awesome job making a coherent story line, while removing the bulk of unnecessary silliness. Only complaint is that the new subtitles were overly crude at times and alien voices were a bit awkward. He made Jar Jar genuinely funny at times, which was impressive. I look forward to seeing what you can do, adywan. I think "Lucas Apologists" would be the correct term for those who try to justify anything GL does...

Did you watch the avi file or the DVD? The dvd copy has 4 sets of subtitles- the newest version (ADigitalMan '04) is much more refined and less crude- i.e. no Jar Jar swears. :P I can agree with you on the alien voices though. Personally, I got used to it within 20 minutes or so.

And @ Stewie, I'm interested to see what you're doing to the prequels. Can't wait to see the finished products.

Where can one obtain a copy of this edit?

Luke Vader said:

Octorox said:

Give the head of Luke seen in Vader's mask on Dagobah sith eyes. I think that could really enhance this scene

Great idea!!! And do the same in ROTJ when Luke is about to kill Vader then make them return to normal when he realizes what he's about to become.

And no...Not a good idea at all!!!