logo Sign In

Post #321605

Author
AuggieBenDoggie
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/321605/action/topic#321605
Date created
23-Jun-2008, 7:44 PM
GoodMusician wrote:
No rush Ady... ;-) We're just kinda idly debating lol


Yeah, no rush Ady, it's just friendly debating. No worries.

The reason I demostrated the original cue (yes, that's the ORIGINAL Probe Droid cue) rather than the film alternate is that is Ady is going to be rebuilding the Sound field, then the alternate will produce more problems than it will solve.

For one, the music quality is different than the rest becuase it was one of a couple tracks that are improperly and haphazardly mixed on the SE.

Two, it's missing a few bars which enable the transition between it and the music as Luke is on the taun taun.

And lastly, to simply show what it was like.

As for the request to mix in the sfx, I've done that before... but my video got pulled from YouTube... I'll post it again here if you'd like...


The original unused cue Williams wrote is just too loud and distracting for the most part IMO. It does; however, work for a couple of scenes in your clip IMO. But I really cant officially judge until Ady rebuilds the soundtrack. But as it stands right now in my opinion, I believe Lucas made a good call to the cut the original cue williams wrote, and implement one that not so distracting.

No offence to you at all GoodMusician, people have their prefferences.