logo Sign In

Post #321270

Author
ImperialFighter
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/321270/action/topic#321270
Date created
20-Jun-2008, 8:03 AM
ImperialFighter said:

seven said:


When Luke does into the cave and see's Darth Vader, you hear his Lightsaber activate off screen. Next shot is Luke holding his lightsaber at the bottom of the screen, when he slowly starts to raise it, we see the blade color 'pop' on instead of already being on


seven - Never actually noticed that one in the past if it's right. That's one of the sort of subtle touches that doesn't really matter if it's done or not, but really nice if it is kind of thing that would be good to see after years of rewatches. :)


Having now had a chance to check this one out, and study it a little, the shot seems okay to me. 'Freeze-framing' both the SE and GOUT versions at this point revealed that there has been some work done to the SE release here, compared to the GOUT release. Luke's Lightsaber blade has been changed, and a subtle glowing 'aura' is now evident when we first see it now. However, rather than the Lightsaber and it's glowing 'aura' suddenly 'popping on', I think it's just how it looks as it first appears in the frame, and is correct. Just offering another point of view on that one seven.



You have some nice ideas there by the way GoodMusician, especially on the score aspect of things (and I REALLY like that 'wisp of cloud swirling around as the Millennium Falcon turns through the clouds back to get Luke', Adywan), and it's great to generally see that some folks like yourself and others here, seem to be afflicted with the same 'curse' for 'continuity details' as myself, LOL!

topdawg193 - Your idea for some subtle graphics in those shots is neat.

RoccondilRinon - Nice call on the shadows there.

GoodMusician - Agreed about the shot at top being the far better one. I never would have spotted that in a million years, lol.

Ady - The bottom screengrab shows what I meant the other day about the 'little' Chewbacca being quite high up out of his snowcrater, and with his arms very close to his sides, compared to the immediate previous 'close-up' shot of him lower down, and with his arms outstretched at the sides.