I really enjoyed the other DOOM (Possesed) edit mentioned above just as much as I will probably enjoy yours. There was some interesting things the fan editor of the film did that I enjoyed. Ofcourse everyone is entitled to their own opionions but I still stay clear of coming across as put downs.
If someone wants to be a constructive critic on FAN EDITS that's another story. I understand what your are saying that it may have left you dissapointed but those critics things I reserve for a private messages. I am sure he wouldn;t get mad at you if you emailed him some of your thoughts. It's his fan edit - it's his vision of the way HE wants it. Just like your vision will be the way you want it! See what I am saying?
Anyway's I am sure you didn't mean it like it comes across above.
I can't wait for yours to be realized, The idea looks awesome. I am impressed!
Thanks