gavin77 said:

Hayden is a little weak at times, but to me Mark Hamill is way, way worse of an actor.

Not to me. Hamill gave a fine, natural performance in SW- I don't think you can really say that about Hayden in either of his PT films. Mark's acting got a little self-conscious as the trilogy progressed, but he still gave believable, moving performances in ESB and ROTJ. The thing about Mark's performances in those 3 films that I always appreciated was that he bought what he was doing. I never doubted for a minute that he WAS Luke Skywalker, and he believed he was. I never got that sense of commitment from Hayden.

Sorry, I know we're not supposed to talk about the PT anymore in here. :-P