I wouldn't really trust CHUD's reviews of the film. I love the site (most entertaining way to get my movie news), but they always seem to have their minds made up on a movie from the moment it's announced. They've taken the position that Indy 4 was going to be bad for a while now, so it doesn't surprise me that their reviews are as negative. Heck, looking at the # ratings they've given the film, it's pretty ridiculous when most reviews have been generally favorable. They seem to be treating the movie with extra scrutiny.