Sevb32 said:

So there will be no musical number in Jabba's palace period? Of course this is a long way off. I couldn't care less right now.

Are you going to cut out all the newer windows in cloud city? Cut the crowd scenes during Lando's evacuation announcements? Add more sky traffic of people evacuting the city as the falcon escapes?

When you say something "does not work" you say it as if it's absolute fact and not just an opinion. Unless you mean that it's a fact that it is your opinion.

Now you are just being childish just because i'm cutting your precious shuttle scene. i have been patient with you until now but you are really starting to piss me off. I have told you the reasons why i will be cutting those scenes time and time again. THEY ARE GONE.PERIOD. I stated right from the start that this version will be closer to the original release with most of the SE additions cut out. Do you have a problem reading what i write? I say that things don't work because that's the way i feel and nothing more. It is my edit after all. you seem to prefer the SE's over the original so this edit will not be for you. Everyone has an opinion and different tastes and i respect that but to keep going on time and time again becomes annoying. And you wonder why people start attacking you. There will be a lot of SE additions that i will be keeping. Most of the new windows, if not all, in cloud city will be in the final edit also.

Sevb32 said:

How is the Wampa some unknown terror when there was a 1980 toy of him and now that we've seen it, how can we be automatically scared again? Maybe true for a new watcher, but no one else.

Big deal there was a toy of him. Just because we have seen him doesn't mean to say that the mystery and suspense can't still be there in a movie now that we have seen him in the SE. In the original Alien movie we never really get to see the alien, same as the wampa in the OUT. But since we have more Alien movies and we know exactly what it looks like but does the fact that we know what it looks like now make Alien lose its suspense? No. Good monsters are the ones that we either never see until the end or just catch the tiniest of glimpses of now and then. The original Wampa edit worked great so i want to return it close to that.

Sevb32 said:

How about ALL the Vader shuttle shots strung together in an extras section? Like you did the ANH Jabba scene. How does that sound? Is it a fair compromise?

Why should i feel the need for any sort of compromise? Its not as if you haven't got the SE DVD so you can see it any time you want.The Jabba scene was exactly that... a scene.It was included because i had already done some work on the colour correction and i was doing the 3D version. The shuttle is just a few random clips so NO it won't be in the extras.

Can you please just quit it now because its just going to turn into one big slanging match between members and the whole thread will become a mess. I need to be able to keep track of all the ideas thrown my way but all this has become a huge distraction. You seem to have changed personality completely from when you first came on the boards. You were very supportive and i appreciate that but this change in personality almost seems like someone else has hijacked your account.

I welcome all you input but you must realise that once i have decided to do something then no amount of pushing will get me to change my mind. In fact i will end up doing the opposite.