A nice fair-handed review there, -1. :) As you correctly said, this was never meant to replace the original (that Lucas is sorry so many of us fell in love with...*shaking fist*) and never will. It's just a fun and extremely impressive and lovingly crafted take on the movie. It will never be for everyone, but even the hardest of the hardcore have to be impressed by much of the content, even if it's just the ridiculous amount of color correction.