guitarfan01 said:

So, is it alright to ask for these things (mind you, I'm not asking)?

This is covered in the FAQ (see #12b). Basically, it's alright to use the forum to ask for commentaries off laserdiscs - it's still technically illegal, but we hope that the copyright police won't bother to come after Jay if it's obsolete stuff that's being shared.

joebshmoe said:

boon et al will chime in for the official comment, etc.

Ouch!

ReverendBeastly said:

I'd love to get a rip of the Stardust commentary somehow.

You need to read the FAQ as well. (Unless you were asking how to rip the audio track off the Region 2 DVD that you have legitimately purchased - in which case, post your query in the technical help forum.)