Taolar said:
Hey Adywan,
I had a showing of your NTSC DVD-5 version over the weekend for 10 people on a huge 8 foot wide projection system, and people loved it. There were actually no complaints over any of the changes you made.
But a few people, including myself, noticed that the audio gets slightly out of sync after they leave Tatooine, up until the destruction of Alderan. I know a couple other people on this forum mentioned noticing that a while back, but at that time I watched those scenes over and over again on my computer and it didn't seem out of sync.
Maybe it's only noticeable when the image was blown up so large and the movements of lips are that much more visible. Or maybe the problem is only on the center channel, which is why I never noticed it with my stereo headphones...?
I noticed it at about 55:10, starting when Han says "Go strap yourselves in..." Watch when he says "light speed". Han makes the "sp" sound with his lips after it was already said. I'm watching it on my computer now, running the ISO from my hard drive, with Media Player Classic, and I do notice it out of sync there, but the scene that follows seems synced to me. But watching it on that huge screen, with a nice 5.1 sound system, the dialog ran about 2 or 3 frames earlier than the video up until Alderaan blows up. It wasn't apparent to everyone, even after it was pointed out. But three people did notice it, without me bringing it up. Afterwards everything was in sync again.
Anyway, not a huge issue, but I thought I'd bring it up again in case you wanted to double check it before the DVD-9.
-T
Hasn't that scene always been like that? I seem to remember the 04 dvd having the same issue....haven't checked though, just going off my faulty memory...