Yes, I think it would. I am also a very big fan of the NPR version. The extras and expansion are welcome, however I don't think it could ever replace my love of the original (SE too, only the '04 DVDs do I despise) trilogy.

I didn't grow up in a house of star-wars obsessed, it's of my own desire that I'm totally crazy for it. So, my dad never complained/was happy in particular about the special editions. It is my own curiosity/inner preservationalist (is that a word?) that makes me want to see a competent release of it.

I would be very happy, very. Maybe I'd lose some interest, maybe I'd gain some.