logo Sign In

Post #312995

Author
auximenies
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/312995/action/topic#312995
Date created
8-Mar-2008, 8:46 PM
Just watched the part from the carbon freeze scene through "i am your father", and here's what needs attention:

1. When the carbon freeze first engages, is there a way to see Hans hands come up in front of him (implying the freeze broke the binders and his natural reaction was to raise his arms in front of him)?

2. When Boba Fett fires at Luke, his first shot misses but his second hits the edge of the wall. When we see his third(?) shot hit the wall, the edge where the second shot hit looks untouched.

3. During the duel, after Vader falls below and "disappears", Luke jumps down. The sound of him landing implies it was a ways down, but we see him stand up, revealing that his hop was only a short distance down. I think Uncanny Antman was referring to this when, on 17-Feb-2008, he wrote "1:45:18 - Erase Luke’s head popping up at the last moment."

4. Just before Luke flies out the window, his saber is ignited. When he flies out the window, there is no saber in his hand. If you add the hilt to his hand while he's heading out the window, there may be time just prior to add the sound effect of de-ignition (is that a word?).

5. If there is any way to prevent Vader's helmet from blowing around in the wind while he is telling Luke of his grandiose plans, please do it. It always drove me nuts that it looks as though that thing might come off at any moment!

6. As the good guys are running through Bespin enroute to the Falcon, there are some inconsistencies in the lighting as a result of the added CGI exteriors.

Adywan, I realize you're in wind-down mode after SW:ANH:R, but would it be possible to update the first post to list suggestions that you are aware of, and perhaps annotate them? You could mark each one Y, N, or M (yes, will be changing; no, won't be changing; maybe will change, not yet sure). This way we could be aware of all the things that have been thrown out there, even if you're not going to make a certain change.

Thanks for all your work!