logo Sign In

Post #311955

Author
DarthBo
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/311955/action/topic#311955
Date created
1-Mar-2008, 12:07 PM
Originally posted by: sgdelta1771
Originally posted by: discostewart
I also agree some kind of scene showing how the ATATs got to the surface would be great. As for now they just appear. Surely they mustahve some kind of Transformer type element where n space the4y just look like cargo boxes. Probably too ambitious though.

Here's an idea -- maybe you can show these 'dropships' launching from an Imperial Star Destroyer. Filiming new scenes or completely using new CGI to create a scene on Hoth would probably be too hard.

But WHY?
Seriously, you all complain about George adding unnecessary things just because he CAN. Now you want to add scenes that have no use?
I mean Vader says it all doesn't he? "Prepare for ground assault", "land your troops outside the shield", ... why would you need to see any of that? There's no purpose! It would also destroy the slow reveal of the walkers, one of the most awesome Star Wars moments, which should not be touched imho.

Please just fix the things that need to be fixed, don't go adding in things just because you think it'd be fun to see.