Hello! first time posting! I stumbled upon this while looking to see if the rumours are true: that there's a fan edit that it's truer to the Star Wars mythos than the Lucasfilm DVD's and I can only say: it's true, never watching the "official" ep 4 again....Adywan you have done things I had only imagined before and to see them now in crystal clear format it's great, I was so happy to see we can make suggestions

this time.....if I may give my opinion here

Originally posted by: Chrille

I like that you will try to make the Emperor hologram look closer to how he looked in ROTJ, but I still maintain that the best and simplest thing to do is simply to darken the hologram so that most of his face is not visable.

Think of the scene in ROTJ when Palpatine lands in the hangar bay. As he and Vader walks and talks, only his mouth, chin and the lower part of his left cheek is visible. That's how I think it should be in ESB as well.

I agree with Chrille here, make the hologram scarier, darker, and more similar to the final Emperor. Also an idea I toyed around in my mind and want to share is that we hardly see Coruscant in the OT so what if the conversation with Vader could go like this: when Vader talks to the hologram it's onboard the SD, but at the beginning of the conversation after he says "what is thy bidding..." the camera goes to Coruscant and we see from behind (to avoid spoiling the ROTJ revelation) the Emperor talking to a Vader hologram answering the greeting, and so the conversation goes back and forth in the two places....I dunno if that's feasable but it's fun to think about it and it would be cooler if it could be seen.

Besides that just adding more imperial troops and AT-AT's at the Hoth attack and MAYBE more ships in space when the rebel base is evacuating....

Some guys have mentioned the errors in cloud city windows, I think that should be fixed too, like in ANH, small subtle fixes that our friends at LFL don't have a sharp eye to catch! hehe. Still in the end Adywan it's your edit, and I know it will look great.