logo Sign In

Post #309617

Author
KubrickFan
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/309617/action/topic#309617
Date created
9-Feb-2008, 6:20 PM
Wow.

Okay, I have just seen it. I don't know what to say . I read all kinds of comments about your edit, and while I am critical, I seriously couldn't be bothered by the 'mistakes' some people listed here. The revealing of the Death Star looked great to me. The additional TIE fighters added to the end battle was a fantastic move. I didn't like Battle of the Heroes added to the duel when you showed the test clip, but now, remixed and re-edited, I couldn't think of being it another way. The lightsabers look great, vibrant and consistent, as they should've been. The Death Star looked dull and gray again (I hope Hoth will look white again, when you are revisiting Empire).
Actually, I could go on and on about it, but most of it has been adressed anyway (and that shows that I'm not the only one who thinks that way about the changes).
And I even found George Lucas (great to put him in) and the battle droid .
The DVD-9 DL with bonus material probably will replace the 2004 dvds as my favorites .

Some questions, though.
The blue hue when the Falcon travels in lightspeed, was that the original 2004 dvd look? Nothing was added to that? It looks way too blue.
Whatever happened to the scene you were going to add to the end? The additional scene with Darth Vader in his shuttle. I would have loved to see that. And why did you did not alter Obi-Wan's line to 'I wanted you to have this, when you were old enough?' Just curious.

I know you're not even close to beginning on them, but I was really curious about this. What are you planning to change to the prequels? They need a lot of improvement. I thought I read something about it, but I couldn't remember exactly.

I have said it already, but I think you have done an incredible job. Thanks .