You're entitled to your opinion just as I'm entitled to mine so on most points we'll just have to agree to disagree. Personally, I find it objectionable when a guy has worked his ass off for 18 months straight on something that he will be giving away for FREE only to encounter a thread full of people "nit-picking" and requesting tweaks, fixes, changes, etc. The quote from Ady "now I know how George Lucas feels" summed it up perfectly. Some Star Wars fans will NEVER be happy and nothing is going to change that. Ady could go back and make every minor change that's been requested in this thread and then have a whole new list of requests thrown his way. It never ends!!! Personally, I think we're all lucky to have someone as devoted as Ady to take the time and fix all of the things that were wrong with the 1997 and 2004 Special Editions. Will his edit be 100% perfect? No, it won't be, but it will still be a helluva lot better than the two efforts we got from Lucasfilm and to me that speaks volumes.
Hopefully we can put all this useless bickering to rest once and for all and just look forward to the DVD release.