Originally posted by: Kurgan

I sense the pride and loyalty these folks have for him that they feel protective, but some of it just comes off as patronizing, if not rude.

I don't want to derail this thread any further, but I just have to call BS on this statement. How is it patronizing or rude to defend Adywan after he's said that he has done everything he originally envisioned with this edit and that he doesn't want to make any further changes? I'm sure there are little fixes here and there he could address, but he's stated time and time again that he's satisfied with the edit and officially done with it. The "rude" people are the ones who keep pestering him to make additional tweaks or changes. My feeling is this: either enjoy it for what it is, the best SW fan edit ever and something that surpasses what Lucas gave us in 1997 and 2004, or move along and don't bother watching it.