logo Sign In

Post #307862

Author
Kurgan
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/307862/action/topic#307862
Date created
23-Jan-2008, 5:13 PM
I guess I didn't understand how PIF worked. I just planned to mail copies out to 3-4 of my friends, absorbing all the costs involved myself (none of them are regulars here that I know of, and only one I know for sure has a working DVD-burner). I highly doubt they'll be mailing 3 copies each, so if that's the case, best to leave me off so I don't get on somebody's sh** list. I want a copy as much as anyone else, but I can wait an extra week to get mine if it means avoiding becoming a pariah around here.


Btw, what is it with people getting so angry over the constructive criticism of the movie? Relax. Adywan asked for feedback. If he can't handle that, then he shouldn't have asked...

But he's made it over 18 months with people's feedback, so I don't think people's dreams of him doing ESB and ROTJ will be shattered just because he got too many posts asking him to fix the flipper (my idea) or the TIE shot (I have no gripe with that one).

Notice how he decided to fix a bunch of other things people weren't really complaining about. It's his call what he wants to work on, so I really find the condescending "stop complaining about minor things, this is perfect, be so grateful because this is the best star wars edit ever" gushing really annoying, since it's directed presumably at everyone who gave feedback, not just the people who didn't do so in a polite or constructive enough manner. First everyone responds with their feedback, then everyone is rushing to condemn any and all feedback because it might be hurting ady's feelings and stop him from giving us all the goodies we want from him.

I sense the pride and loyalty these folks have for him that they feel protective, but some of it just comes off as patronizing, if not rude.