logo Sign In

Post #307734

Author
AuggieBenDoggie
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/307734/action/topic#307734
Date created
23-Jan-2008, 4:45 AM
My reaction to their reactions on the most hated....


WHAT THEY HATED

- Added screams of Rebel soliders getting shot in opening. - I cant believe they hated that?! I'd scream if I got shot by a lazer.
- The re-edited scene in Ben's house. They recognized that it was reworked to the original script, but felt the changes made to the original were done for good reason.- Ady's edit still gets the same point across.
- The first establishing shot of the Death Star. Too busy, the elements don't match and the Star Destroyer is sliding across the screen.-It was pretty evident that the elements were different, but it still looked professional.
- ALL music that has been added. Especially to the Lightsaber fight. -Thats debateable, alot are going to like it, and alot wont. It's there to give energy to the fight.
- The added effects to the torture probe needle. Just wasn't neccessary. - it works either way.
- New lightsabers are too fat.- Now thats BS, look at the prequel sabers ( episode3 in particular ) they are fat at the base and taper off to a point at the end, and the gradients don't fade off very well either. Nothing like the classics.
- The Falcon exiting hyperspace near Yavin.- I don't get it, it's such a short shot, and it still looked good IMO.
- The big TIE fighter reveal.It doesn't really bother me, but I didn't hate it by any means.