Ady and his small team have done incredible, very professional work. It's 95% to the same standards we work towards on prime-time TV shows. I was very serious when I said that Ady could use his edit as a resume and get a job at probably any effects studio in Hollywood. I know I would hire him!
With that in mind, I just would love to see EVERY shot in his cut held to the same standard. I know it's a matter of taste, and I know a lot of people think the shot is fine, and maybe it's because I am used to seeing things with the utmost scruitiny, but in my view that is one of the only shots in the edit that holds it back from being perfect, and I have so much adoration and respect for what Ady has done I WANT to see it perfect!
I know it's very arrogant and presumptuous of me (welcome to my reputation), but I am confident that if presented with some alternatives Ady (and I think most of the community) would see what I mean. [And no, I don't mean to introduce hand-held style camera; Star Wars is not the place for that. By simply having the TIES moving faster and having the camera slowly panning with them from the outset, the shot would feel considerably more dynamic.]
And I'd love to help him fix that Death Star background!