Originally posted by: adywan

Otherwise, the way i'm feeing at the moment, ESB is a dead project. I'm just happy that the majority like what i've done. I knew i'd never be able to please everyone, but come on..

Now thats just plain wrong, don't take the criticism that hard man. I have done alot of stuff that has gotten the same type criticism on other websites ( non starwars related ). I knew right away when following this project that you would get criticism; however, I didn't expect it to be effects related. With what content you have shown us during your progress, it looked to be a virtually error free reedit, and for the most part it is, and beyond. Mainly what you have are just a few FX shots that are getting some heat. Nobody is going to think less of you for keeping them as they are, and it wont effect me either way if you choose not to change them.

I'm really happy to see that virtually everybody ( including me ) really enjoy what you have done story wise, ( bens hubble, end battle ect.. ) George Lucas should take some serious notes from your release. And about ESB, that should be a cake walk for you. You would manily be taking out some of the SE shots and changes that didn't need to be in it in the first place, it's nothing near the shape A New Hope was in. I say forge ahead, and finnish the classic trilogy, it is your destiny......