Originally posted by: Mojo_LA
I really think the flipper debate has missed the biggest point - whether or not it would be a hand or a flipper, in the few seconds we have to see the shot, a human hand simply has more emotional impact. With the flipper, it takes a few seconds - or even a repeat viewing - to know what you're looking at. This could be the #1 reason Lucas went with a hand.

I think it's pretty well established that the flipper prop wasn't available for the shot, so Lucas went with what he had on hand, if you'll pardon the pun. Someone will take me out back and spank me if I'm wrong. But I agree with your point completely (though I 100% disagree about the TIE shot). The hand is the better dramatic choice. If you're a SW geek who is already aware that Ponda Boba has flippers (they're hardly the focus of the quick shot that shows them, most people would miss that) and is already aware that Ponda is the one that gets sabered, the shot makes perfect sense. Someone watching the film for the first time, or even the tenth (and I realize they're not the target audience), or is otherwise going into that scene without the aforementioned knowledge, would only be confused. I've watched it countless times, and I was confused.

But once again, disclaimer time for the easily upset: Ady, do it however makes you happy, bro.

Ron Moses