criticism aside, I'm extremely grateful that Adywan has created the definitive version of Episode 4 as far as I'm concerned this will be the version of the film that I choose to watch from now on, but how many of us would be on this forum if we weren't a little bit anal about one of our alltime favourite films? We would have just taken what George gave us in 2004 and been happy with it.

you're never gonna please all of the people all of the time, but I think Adywan has come closer to pleasing everyone 100% than anyone else has before. and If I was to list all of the things I loved about his revision then we'd be here for weeks.

it'd just be a real shame to all his hard work if someone used his edit and just added that last bit of icing to the cake and made the 'flipper' work.