Finished downloading, and scanned the movie through a bit. One word: WOW!!! The duel really is better paced, and the music mix throughout the film is great. The holograms are excellent, really as they should be, and bring the movie closer technology-wise to the PT, without being to in-your-face changes. The battle droid is there, but hardly noticeable, just the head. I had to pause just to be sure. I'll probably spot George when I see the whole movie. Regarding the flipper - I does look a bit 'flat', but on the other side, he is an alien, and to me that shoot Is all about the light-saber wound, not the flipper-hand. It is the show the strength of the light-saber, the cleanness of the cut. I don't really care for the flipper shape.

I know you are probably very tired after this edit, but I was wondering, do you plan to start the Empire edit relatively soon? Maybe in a couple of months. Will you start a new thread, the same as for this edit? We already made some suggestions in one thread about ESB and ROTJ. After gathering a lot of experience in the process of making ANH Revisited, you can probably concentrate more on the content side of the upcoming edits and less on the technical side. I hope your 'tech' 3D team will keep on supporting you in the new edits. And off course, as there is less to correct/add/change in the ESB and ROTJ, and you are now an experienced editor, the editing process will be much shorter I suppose.