logo Sign In

Post #302133

Author
C3PX
Parent topic
Ian McDiarmid's performance in the PT (also the OT) is memorable and absolutely enthralling
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/302133/action/topic#302133
Date created
28-Nov-2007, 11:45 AM
Originally posted by: Sevb32
I don't believe there was a problem with the make-up, we saw him ONLY hooded in ROTJ, in ROTS we saw him unhooded and also in many various lighting conditions, in ROTJ he was pretty much in only ONE lighting condition. I assure you if that hood was flipped down in ROTJ and in several different lighting conditions people would be saying the same thing about the ROTJ make-up.


You are forgetting that we see him with the hood on in ROTS and he looks VERY different. You are also forgetting that we see him in the 2004 version of ESB and he looks very different. You are also not taking into account how very different the coloring and everything else about the two different masks. It has absolutely NOTHING to do with hoods or lighting. Not even in the slightest. That would be like saying the reason the Yoda puppet in TPM looks different from the one in ESB and ROTJ is not because of sculpting, but because we have only ever seen him in the dim fire light of his hut and in TPM we are seeing him for the first time under real lights. Utter nonsense.