logo Sign In

Post #301382

Author
zombie84
Parent topic
Why Anakin should have been 20 years old in TPM.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/301382/action/topic#301382
Date created
15-Nov-2007, 11:50 PM
I like this idea CO. I don't think he needed to be 20--just of an adult mind-set. Personally the age of 17-18 is when this type of personal discovery is most potent, and the sort of ego development is most potent at this age as well.
Actually, this idea reminds me of the ending of Rocky. The original ending for that film was to continue after the fight, showing Rocky and Adrian in the empty arena, all the audience gone, some janitor sweeping up, and they would walk out the door back into anonyminity after this one night in the spotlight. But the most important change came in ending the film just before this, at the pinnacle of Rocky's victory--the idea being that we are freeze-framing on this one moment of his life when he will never be happier, that everything in his life had been building to that moment of happiness and everything after it is downhill, so we freeze-frame on him in absolute bliss and immortalise that moment in time.

That was the thing the prequels never really go--having an actual fall. I mean yeah Anakin is sort of a good guy that became evil, but its so much more tragic if he's actually a hero, the way we were told he was supposed to be. Theres nothing really heroic about Anakin in TPM or AOTC--he saves the day as a kid by complete fluke, then rescues his mom because he's obsessed with her, tries to rescue Padme but he's got an even bigger obsession with her, and tries to rescue Obi Wan but after all the arguing and ordering in the film theres not much emotion there and he fails to do this anyway.