logo Sign In

Post #298837

Author
HotRod
Parent topic
Anything? Anything At All? (that is remotely positive or good about the SE and PT?)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/298837/action/topic#298837
Date created
11-Oct-2007, 8:30 AM
I'm with those who quite like the PT for what it is. A set of Star Wars films that is ok, just not up to the original.
What do I like in particular? Dunno.
But one thing I do like (a lot) is the last 10 mins of Sith. Vader and Papls looking at the Death Star (I know the timeline is shagged...but it's just a film man) but I especially love the scene where Obi Wan hands Luke over to Beru. Love that scene...The music, colours..the fact that it's so sad, but we know what is to come. Perfect.

See, if the PT was more like that.....more visual - less dialog.... I think they could have been fantastic to watch.

SE..Meh...But who cares when we have such good Fan edits on here.