logo Sign In

Post #297917

Author
beej199
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/297917/action/topic#297917
Date created
27-Sep-2007, 5:24 PM

...........Well i hate the new shuttle sequences added to the end of ESB. they just break up the flow of the action. I don't mind the new "alert my stardestroyer..." section but the rest has to either be minimised to one shot or gone completely. Also they add a nice new window in cloud city just before they meet Vader but for the rest of the sequence the window is back to its pre-SE appearance. ...........


Adywan

Couldnt agree more. One thing that has annoyed with this new scene is the fact that James Earl Jones's voice is out of place with the action, you would expect a more annoyed tone of voice coming from Darth Vader at this point in the movie. There is a definite air of irritation in his tone all the way through ESB until this scene where Darth Vader then reverts to a just requesting a shuttle in a formal manner. He should have sounded incredibly "irritated "at this point rather than "matter of fact" delivery that was added in the SE. Im sure I heard that this dialogue track was actually part of ESB originally anyway but was cut although I find it hard to believe? although it may have been part of Star Wars?

Anyway Id be tempted to drop this whole scene and revert to the original format, who cares if we dont see Darth travel from cloud city to his star destroyer?

Anyway thats off topic. Keep up the good work with Star Wars! I havent watched Star Wars in over a year and a half now in anticipation of your version and during this time have even bought a widescreen TV and have yet to test it with my OT discs!!