I have debated JediRandy on TFN and ORS, and he actually isn't this PT gusher that he comes off as, as he is pretty reasonable, but he is just the type of guy who just doesn't hate Lucas the same way we do for the suppression of the OOT, and thinks were a bunch of whiners. So in a sense, he agrees with us on our assessment of the movies, he just isn't as passionate about it as we are, and he is trying to goad us with his posts.
I say to everyone, enjoy his posts with a grain of salt, and if nobody replies to him and he believes he isn't getting us, he will go away.