Originally posted by: Kurgan
I think folks are still misunderstanding me, but here I'll post the details from this already released project. It's your choice of course, but read it over... I'm NOT talking about pasting the Behind the Magic clips in as is. I'm talking about MoveAlong's conversion of the scenes to an acceptable format on DVD:
Kurgan i think it is you that is misunderstanding what has been said. There is no possible way that these scenes taken from the BTM disc could ever be used in an edit like mine that uses DVD or HD resolution video. Upscaling to DVD format will not give you any more detail than the original source that could ever be acceptable to use. Even if miracles could be performed and you could get the detail in the deleted scenes to the level of the 2004 DVDs then the framerate issue would still kill any chance of using these. I have read that thread and seen the amazing work MoveAlong did for the DVD & boba feta has done on the restoration but if you asked any one of them then they would agree with what i have said. Also the story changed in its final edit to how it was originally filmed so the scenes just don't fit in without some extensive editing as i explained in my last reply to you which you just seemed to have dismissed.
Originally posted by: Kurgan
My advice, is to at least watch this disc before it's dismissed out of hand...
I think folks are still misunderstanding me, but here I'll post the details from this already released project. It's your choice of course, but read it over... I'm NOT talking about pasting the Behind the Magic clips in as is. I'm talking about MoveAlong's conversion of the scenes to an acceptable format on DVD:
Kurgan i think it is you that is misunderstanding what has been said. There is no possible way that these scenes taken from the BTM disc could ever be used in an edit like mine that uses DVD or HD resolution video. Upscaling to DVD format will not give you any more detail than the original source that could ever be acceptable to use. Even if miracles could be performed and you could get the detail in the deleted scenes to the level of the 2004 DVDs then the framerate issue would still kill any chance of using these. I have read that thread and seen the amazing work MoveAlong did for the DVD & boba feta has done on the restoration but if you asked any one of them then they would agree with what i have said. Also the story changed in its final edit to how it was originally filmed so the scenes just don't fit in without some extensive editing as i explained in my last reply to you which you just seemed to have dismissed.
Originally posted by: Kurgan
My advice, is to at least watch this disc before it's dismissed out of hand...
well actually i have had a copy of this disc since MoveAlong released it so i have not just dismissed it out of hand as you say. And i have just read your post in MoveAlong's thread and it seems that you haven't got the disc yourself because you're asking for seeders so my advice to you would be to first watch the disc yourself, then compare it to the 2004 DVDs so you will see what i have tried twice now to explain to you before rudely telling me what to do like that when i have actually watched the disc & do know what i am talking about.