logo Sign In

Post #293048

Author
musicman
Parent topic
Episode 3 - Editing Back in Progress (* unfinished project *)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/293048/action/topic#293048
Date created
21-Jul-2007, 12:15 AM
CC! Hey, I'll comment on your clips in the Starkiller Ranch thread, okay?

Cool ideas, here, GM. The vision idea is interesting. Two things on the audio end of it: 1) The way you've mixed and reverbed Qui-Gon and Yoda's lines thus far makes it sound more like Yoda is remembering these things. I think a bit of a balance between what ADM did and what you have would probably make it more clear that that's what's going on. (I love that "You doubt the prophecy?" line, although I also like ADM's line selection as well--it would be nice to see both aspects of Yoda's current state addressed by Qui-Gon: guilt, like in ADM's, and doubt, like in yours).

The second thing is: would it be possible to edit Yoda's line to be "A prophecy could have been misread"? That and "Around the survivors, a perimeter create" are probably the most annoying lines from Yoda. In fact, if it could be done, I think some un-inversion throughout the PT would be good. It just got to be overkill. I'm amazed when I look back at the OT, and how normally Yoda speaks so much of the time.

I love your idea for Obi-Wan checking on Padme in the ship!

I did notice an improvement in having Bail's line more prominent here; that's good, in that it's supposed to disrupt Yoda's meditation and vision.

That's about all I have for now. Good work, GM! Keep going!