I can't say that all the singing is bad. Some of it is good. And the few that made the movie were good. I especially enjoyed Pippen in ROTK singing to Denethor while Faramir goes to battle. That was so beautifully filmed. But if I had to sit through the Hobbits singing while hiking (a la Stand by Me) or have everyone singing around a campfire throughout the movie, I would probably get very angry. And we know what happens when I get angry, right, Mr. McGee?
I can't say that all the singing is bad. Some of it is good. And the few that made the movie were good. I especially enjoyed Pippen in ROTK singing to Denethor while Faramir goes to battle. That was so beautifully filmed. But if I had to sit through the Hobbits singing while hiking (a la Stand by Me) or have everyone singing around a campfire throughout the movie, I would probably get very angry. And we know what happens when I get angry, right, Mr. McGee?