I remember turning to my friend after watching TPM and asking, "Did that feel like Star Wars to you?" And he shook his head "no." And I wanted to like the film.

After watching AOTC, I was gobsmacked. Again, I remember asking my friend if it "felt" like Star Wars to him, and again, he said, "no." I was very disappointed.

ROTS I didn't watch until it was video. I just couldn't shake the cartoony-digity aura about it. Again, disappointed. Again, did not feel like Star Wars. I wanted to like this one, especially after reading posts of those hated the first two, but liked this one.