I actually enjoyed all 3 PT movies upon my initial viewings, as I wasn't EVER expecting them to be to the OT standards, so it was more like, "That was cool to see more SW movies." I think the replay value of the movies is where they don't hold up, as they just arent' as entertaining, and I don't think TPM & AOTC aren't really designed to be watched 8,000 times like many of us do with the OT movies. My disdain over the years towards the PT has been solely cause the OOT has been thrown to the wolves, and I believe the release of the OOT in great quality, would make me take the PT for whats its worth, "Part of the SW-lore now, but really not interested in watching the movies anymore."