I am really not surprised by ROTS being in second. I myself do not think it deserves to be there, but I hear a lot of people ( people who are not obsessed over star wars and just like the movies as popcorn flicks and nothing else) say that ESB is their favorite with ROTS being their second favorite. I do not know why, but ROTS when I first saw it was my third favorite behind ESB and ANH, but for some reason now I can't really decide whether I love it or hate it. There is just something about it that causes me love it sometimes and hate it other times. It isn't something a fanedit could cure it is just something that I can't stand about the movie.