logo Sign In

Post #283961

Author
pittrek
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP IV 2004 REVISITED ADYWAN *1080p HD VERSION NOW IN PRODUCTION
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/283961/action/topic#283961
Date created
24-Apr-2007, 3:26 AM
I always ignore fan edits. ALWAYS. I think about these things the same as Neil S. Bulk, but after reading ALL 50+ pages of this thread I became interested in it and I decided to take a closer look. So I have downloaded yesterday the official trailer and the Vader-OB1 duell (all other links are dead) and I must say - WONDERFULL JOB !

But now the critics - there are two wrong things. The one is the planet before the Death Star in the trailer, it looks completely wrong, I don't know why, but simply it doesn't "feel right" there.

The second - the music during the Vader - Kenobi duel. It's terrible. Not the music, it's great like everything John Williams wrote, BUT ... it doesn't belong to the scene. It completely takes you away from the drama and completely RUINS the emotional balance of the scene. The music has absolutely nothing to do with the scene, it's the same as if you watch a movie, you're concetrating on it and your neighbour suddenly turns on the radio. The same ruining of the scene. When you're watching it, you concentrate on the music, and not on the action which is happening on the screen, and then you suddenly realise that Obi is dead.

The rest of your project looks VERY interesting .... Especially the starfield and the spaceships, MUCH better than the original or the special edition !