It is definately illegal, so yes you could get in trouble for it. I would think the website route is definately the wrong one. Cassidy's idea about setting up an ebay auction every time one of theirs pops up would probably be the way to go. It is still illegal, but so far ebay doesn't seem to have much interests in cracking down on illegal DVD sales, so I don't see why your case would be any different. You would also have a good case that you were not selling them for profit, but giving them away to help prevent others from profiting illegally, but I am not sure they would see that as fair justification. I wouldn't worry about people like TR-47 trying to report you because you are ruining his auctions, they are in the same bed and stand to get themselves in trouble too.